top of page

Why Did the NHL Fail in Atlanta...twice?

Writer: Dori
Dori
May 10
4 min read

When news broke that North Point Mall in Alpharetta, Georgia may be repurposed into a new NHL arena, it reopened a question Atlanta has faced twice before: can hockey actually work here? Even after losing the Flames and Thrashers? Here is my perspective — as an Atlanta native.


Photo by Kevin C. Cox / GettyImages
Photo by Kevin C. Cox / GettyImages

Melting Pot of the South


Atlanta is considered a melting pot due to its growing and diverse nature. It is also known as a transplant city with 37% of the population being born in another state. The Hartsfield-Jackson airport is also considered a worldwide hub with many people flying in and out of there.


In recent years, Atlanta has boomed because of film, technology, music, and...sports! After all, we are home to many successful franchises like the Braves, Hawks, Falcons, and United. All of these teams have delivered with successful seasons and packed venues. In fact, Atlanta is a host city for the World Cup this year (2026).


With diverse population comes equally diverse interest. There are several successful teams in the southern region like the Carolina Hurricanes who hold a lead of 8-0 in the 2026 Stanley Cup Finals at time of writing. Florida with its heat and beach culture is able to sustain two ice hockey teams.  In other words, the south is not a hockey culture wasteland. So what’s missing in Atlanta?


A complex market does not mean an incapable one.



We've Seen This Before


You've heard it said: the definition of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results. So it’s worth asking: what went wrong?


The Atlanta Flames were Atlanta's first attempt at a NHL team. They lasted from 1972 to 1980 until relocating to Alberta and becoming what we know today as the Calgary Flames. The Atlanta Flames made the playoffs 6 of their 8 active seasons. Attendance was also steady throughout their run. The real issue was the ownership. Real estate developer Tom Cousins sold the team due to the 1970s market crash. It was reported that Cousins’ money that was not involved in real estate was invested in the Flames. Additionally, they estimated to have lost $12 million USD in their 8 season run.


From 1999 to 2011, Atlanta tried again with the Atlanta Thrashers. They only made the playoffs once in their 11 season run. A company called Atlanta Spirit owned the team and claimed to have lost $130 million USD in the final 6 years of the franchise. They cited that one of the most prominent law firms in Atlanta and faulty legal work was the cause of their financial issues. The Thrashers were then sold and became the Winnipeg Jets. This was another case of poor ownership.


Despite this, both teams had one thing in common. They both claimed there was not enough hockey culture in Atlanta to sustain a fan base. Was there not a culture or did they simply suffer exposure? If there were financial issues related to the downfall, how did they utilize their resources? For example, the Flames had a decent attendance for its time.


From the outside looking in, those were substantial monetary losses from both teams. However, I get the impression that leadership did not care to sustain the team or fan culture.



Going to the Colosseum...


I'd be lying to you if I said I wasn't worried about the Atlanta Gladiators dissolving with the introduction of a new NHL team. They were the first hockey team I ever saw in person, and it will honestly be a core memory for me.


The unfortunate news is I did not know about the existence of a professional hockey team in Atlanta until I actually sought it myself. And it's not that the interest doesn't exist. Anyone I talk to about them is shocked they exist and are eager to go. However, the Gladiators play in a shared arena which makes it difficult to market on the level that a national team usually commands. In fact, the Atlanta Gladiators had record numbers of attendance in the 2025-26 season. They grow despite the obstacles.


There are also multiple minor league, collegiate, and youth leagues from past and present that have kept the culture alive. The Savannah Ghost Pirates are another ECHL team like the Atlanta Gladiators. It serves as more proof that the interest extends beyond the Atlanta metropolitan area.


So the question is not: is Atlanta ready for a new NHL team? It is: is Atlanta ready to take a new team seriously?



Rise Through the Ashes


I genuinely would love to see the new team called the Atlanta Phoenixes. It pays homage to the former NHL teams and proves that Atlanta can indeed rise from the ashes and build a substantial franchise.


Third time is not necessarily a charm but rather an opportunity. The team should not serve to simply generate profit but bring people together like it once did and still does. Despite rivalries and debates, I find that hockey fans are kind and willing to help explain something. And of course, I want a third team for selfish reasons. I would love to see an Atlanta team hoist the Stanley Cup.


Atlanta is ready. What about the NHL?


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Be the first to get new stories.

 

© 2026 by Ice & Wonder

Powered and secured by Wix 

 

bottom of page